Showing posts with label Photo Stitching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Photo Stitching. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2019

Panoramic Photos with GoPro



I enjoy shooting landscape photos, particularly in our U.S. national parks. Sometimes when trying to photograph a wide panoramic view, I simply can’t squeeze the entire landscape into a single photo. That’s when I use a technique where I take multiple side-by-side overlapping images and stitch them together using a software application. A useful tutorial is provided by Digital Photography School.

For most casual photographers, the built-in panoramic setting in mobile phones will suffice, but since I’m a photo geek, I prefer to shoot in RAW, apply color corrections to the individual photos, stitch, rotate, crop, and make other finishing touches. I know it requires a lot more steps, but I like the results and frankly am fascinated by the computations that are involved in the stitching process.

On a recent trip to Maui, I wanted to travel lightly and decided to leave my DSLR at home and shoot only with my iPhone and GoPro. Blasphemy, I know! While hiking in the Summit District of Haleakalā National Park, my iPhone battery died so I began shooting photos and videos with my GoPro HERO7 Black. As expected, I found myself in a scenario where I decided it would be best to take multiple images and later stitch them into a panorama.

Not having previously done this with a GoPro, and recognizing that GoPro cameras have super wide angles and significant barrel distortion, I made sure to overlap each individual photo even more than I usually do with my DSLR. The individual photos are here if you want to play with them:

      
      

Panoramic stitching applications use different methods to combine images, so it is not surprising that I got different results from three photo stitching applications. It is possible that their computational methods are detailed elsewhere, but my main focus is on the end result. Here is a summary of my findings.

Adobe Lightroom Classic CC 2017

Fail. The Panorama Merge feature in Adobe Lightroom was unable to stitch together the GoPro photos.


I got the same result with the other 2 projection options. Granted, this is an older version of Lightroom, and it is possible that the latest version would produce different results. In any case, when it successfully stitches photos, I prefer to use Lightroom for panoramas because it is the focal point of my RAW processing workflow.

PhotoStitcher 1.6

Fail. The application said that there were not enough key points.


I got the same results while trying multiple projection options. Once again, this is an older version, and I have not upgraded to version 2 because I frankly don’t use this application very much.

PTGui Pro 10.0

Winner! This is the application that I used to create the panoramic photo that is pictured at the top of this blog. Here is a screenshot of the unedited preview:


Obviously I haven’t been upgrading my software because version 11 is available at the time of this writing, and I assume that the current version would also successfully stitch the GoPro images.

Conclusion: From this comparison and also from prior experiences, I feel that PTGui is the most powerful stitching tool that I’ve tried. If your only available option is a wide angle lens, and if other applications are unable to create panoramas, try PTGui. However, the old adage that “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” definitely applies here—try to shoot panoramas with a lens that has less barrel distortion to begin with. I hope you’ve found this to be helpful.

Sunday, May 31, 2015

Photo Stitching

Every now and then I find myself in a situation where the focal length of my lens is not wide enough to capture my desired field of view.  While I could certainly whip out my iPhone and use the camera's Landscape feature (which does a pretty nice job in my opinion), there are times when I prefer to create a higher resolution final image, to have the flexibility to adjust shadows/highlight, or to generate a HDR landscape.  In those situations, I take multiple overlapping photos and stitch them together using a desktop application on my iMac.

While there are many well-written articles about to compose your images or adjust your camera settings prior to stitching, in this post I will focus on the post-processing aspect and review 2 applications that have been around for many years: PTGui and DoubleTake.

PTGui. Despite the rather unattractive name of this app (it stands for Panorama Tools Graphical User Interface), I feel like it is excels in many categories.  In particular, it does a very good job of automatically detecting overlapping borders, even in situations where I shoot multiple rows of images.  Additionally, it tends to generate a sufficient number of control points (these are pixels of the overlapping photos that are used as a reference to calculate how photos need to be warped upon stitching) and enables the user to modify or add additional control points to optimize the output.  Finally, when previewing the resultant stitched image, there are multiple presets as well as options to modify the perspective so that you can fine tune the look and feel.

DoubleTake.  While PTGui has more features and possibly has a slightly steeper learning curve, DoubleTake seems to have been created with simplicity in mind.  However, its simplicity is achieved at the expense of capabilities and quality.  For example, while DoubleTake tends to perform well when stitching a single row of overlapping photos, it fails to stitch multiple rows of photos, and I could not figure out how to do it manually either.  If you can get the images to stitch, you can use some alignment features, but most of it feels pretty "automatic" as you can align entire images, but there do not appear to be options to fine-tune the stitching.

There are other photo stitching applications, but these are the only 2 that I have experience with.  I've used PTGui for nearly a decade now, and it has performed exceptionally well for just about every batch of photos I've thrown its way.  While I had evaluated DoubleTake when I first started using PTGui, I thought I'd give it another try to see if it would supplant my current photo stitching workflow, as I assumed the app's feature set would have continued evolving and improving.  However, DoubleTake didn't even come close.  PTGui has served me well, and I'm sticking to it for now.