I recently wrote about a 2-part epic fail with a car rental from Payless here and here. My string of bad luck with car rental companies extended to my very next rental, this time with Hertz.
A couple weeks ahead of time, I reserved my rental car through Hertz via Expedia. On the day before and the day of my car rental, I received text messages to remind me about my reservation.
On 12/1/2025, I picked up my rental car from the Indianapolis International Airport (IND). Upon leaving the car rental facility, an agent asked me for my driver license. She appeared to do some sort of data entry and then handed my driver license back to me and opened the gate to let me through, all without saying another word. I confirmed that I was free to go, to which she nodded, so I was on my merry way.
On 12/6/2025, I filled up the gas tank at the Shell station on the outskirts of the IND and then returned the car to Hertz. Because of my prior car rental for which I was charged $727.41 for “glass damage” that I did not incur, I took photos of the car’s exterior before walking away. I felt that everything went smoothly with this car rental (foreshadowing).
On 12/9/2025, I received an email from Hertz along with an invoice and an unexpected charge on my credit card for $90.25.
I called Hertz to inquire about the charges and specifically asked about the “FUEL & SERVICE” charge for $69.43. The Hertz representative said it was documented that the fuel gauge was 61% when the car was returned. I said that it must have been an error because I verified that the fuel gauge was in fact full after I filled the tank. As an aside, the fuel gauge was analog with markings at 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100%, so how in the world did they determine that it was 61% full? But I digress. I said that I didn’t have a photo of the fuel gauge, but I did have a receipt from the Shell station where I pumped gas immediately before returning the car. Originally the agent asked me to email the gas receipt to customerrelations@hertz.com and ask them to consider reversing the charge. He then placed me on a brief hold and then decided to just process a refund on the spot. I was told that it would take 3-5 business days for me to be credited the $90.25 (by the way, this happened earlier today, and I hope I don’t have to write a follow-up to this post about not getting my refund). He also apologized for the inconvenience and credited my rewards account with 1900 points which he said was enough for 1 free day of rental (I’d be responsible for paying tax on the rental).
Although I was the victim of errors at both Payless and Hertz, I think my experience at Payless was worse. Payless made multiple errors (did not charge car battery, did not give me charging cable, and erroneously charged me for glass damage), and I made more than 20 phone calls to get all of these issues resolved. On the other hand, Hertz made 1 error (erroneously charged me for fuel service), and it took 1 phone call to resolve (again, I have not yet received my refund, so I hope I am not speaking too soon). Additionally, they apologized and issued me reward points. I will probably never use the points because I spread my rentals across many car rental companies based on wherever I can get the best deal, but it was a nice gesture, and I felt that the customer service was better at Hertz. I think I am willing to use Hertz again in the future, but I can’t say the same for Payless.