Showing posts with label Google Photos. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Google Photos. Show all posts

Monday, April 28, 2025

Image Compression: ImageOptim vs. Google Photos

When compressing images such as .jpg or .png files, I usually use ImageOptim which is available as a macOS application as well as an online interface that works with any operating system.

However, did you know that you can accomplish the same thing with Google Photos? As long as you store your photos using Storage Saver mode (which compresses your images, as opposed to original quality which does not compress your photos), you can download them in their compressed state.

I decided to compare file sizes and image quality for these two techniques. For ImageOptim, I enabled all compression methods, opted to strip JPG metadata, and enable lossy minification with JPG quality set to 80%. In all fairness, I do not know if these settings are equivalent to the compression algorithms used by Google Photos, but I believe these were more or less the default settings that were present when I installed ImageOptim.

 

From a recent photo shoot, I edited 93 photos in Adobe Lightroom Classic and exported them in JPG at 90% quality. These 93 JPG photos occupied 530.9 MB. After uploading them to Google Photos and downloading all 93 photos, the collection was compressed to 172.1 MB (32.4% of the original size). After compressing them with ImageOptim, the 93 photos were reduced to 159.7 MB (30.1% of the original size).

In terms of image quality, I cannot see any noticeable degradation in quality when displaying the photos in full screen mode on my 32-inch monitor. It is possible that if I enlarged all photos to 100% magnification I would see artifacts in the compressed images, but for all practical purposes, the compressed images with both Google Photos and ImageOptim look no different to me than the original uncompressed images.

In summary, I observed a minor advantage in file size when compressing JPG images with ImageOptim as compared with Google Photos, but this may simply be due to my ImageOptim compression settings. I think the one advantage of ImageOptim is that you can choose your JPG compression quality, whereas compression with Google Photos is limited to their default settings. Another advantage of ImageOptim is that image compression is quick, whereas compression with Google Photos requires uploading and downloading images so is limited by internet bandwidth. Overall, I find both compression methods to be perfectly suitable for my needs, but I’m sticking with ImageOptim for macOS because of its convenience.

Thursday, November 12, 2020

Google Photos Rescinds Free Unlimited Storage

WAH! I’m crying like a baby as I write this. Google announced that starting June 1, 2021, Google Photos will no longer offer free unlimited storage space. Oh well, it was great while it lasted. Here’s a summary of forthcoming changes:

When Google Photos was launched more than 5 years ago, it provided 2 options for photo storage. The first option was to store the original photo, in which case photos were counted against the default 15 GB storage limit that accompanied each Google account (note that there have been ways to expand beyond the default 15 GB; my account has a 17 GB storage limit). The second option was to store “high quality” images using Google’s image compression algorithms, in which case users were given free unlimited storage space. In my opinion, the high quality option would meet the needs of a vast majority of people since the image compression algorithms did a great job of preserving image quality. I can honestly say that I could not tell the difference between the original and “high quality” compressed images without significantly zooming in to each image. Google later also introduced a third “express backup” option which further limited the size of photos. Read about Google Photos backup options here.

But alas, the free unlimited approach is not sustainable in the long run, so it makes sense that Google would eventually count all photos toward its 15 GB quota. Starting June 1, 2021, users will either need to delete photos to make room for newer ones, or subscribe to a Google One storage plan.

For a customized overview of the Google Photos storage policy, including your personal storage limit and an estimate of how long it will be after you run out of storage, visit https://photos.google.com/storagepolicy.

Thursday, August 10, 2017

Video Processing on Google Photos

For the past 1-2 years, I have been using the Google Photos iOS app on my iPhone to backup all of my photos and videos to my Google account. When a video is uploaded, Google "processes" the video which means it gets converted into a number of different formats and resolutions so it can be played back on different devices and resolutions (similar to what happens when you upload a video to YouTube). Recently I shot numerous videos in 1080p 60fps and synchronized them to Google Photos.  Although I uploaded them on August 5, they were still processing on August 7:

   

However, sometime between August 7 and August 10 (today), the videos finished processing and are now playable. It looks like this issue has been reported in many online forums, and in case others are wondering, my videos eventually became available, I just had to wait a few days.

Despite the delays in video processing, I am still a big fan of Google Photos. A slight delay due to video processing time is a small inconvenience in return for free unlimited compressed (although high quality) backups of photos and videos.

Sunday, January 22, 2017

Bizarre Love Triangle - Photos for iOS, Google Photos, and Photos for macOS

Has this ever happened to you?


In the last 2 years since we both bought a 64 GB iPhone 6 Plus, my wife has rarely deleted photos and videos from her phone. Today she received the above error message. Given that everyone has a finite amount of space on their phones, I thought I'd share my "phonetography" workflow on iOS and macOS. This of course applies to both iPhones and iPads.

1) Take pictures, lots of them. Why not? Storage space is cheap, and memories are precious. Fire away. Turn on HDR and save both the regular and HDR versions. Record video in the maximum resolution and maximum frame rate. View them in Photos for iOS.

2) Periodically sync to Google Photos. As long as you have a Google account, you can upload an unlimited number of photos to your account, provided that you allow Google to apply some compression to your photos. While you currently get 15 GB if you save the original full resolution images from your phones, I think a small amount of compression (no noticeable difference in image quality in my opinion) is worth having unlimited storage. Two reasons for this: most people take rather mediocre smartphone photos and this option is just a backup for hard drive disasters.

3) After syncing to Google Photos, sync photos to Photos for macOS (formerly iPhoto). This will include your original unaltered photos, plus any in-phone edits you might have applied. Also backup these photos to at least 1 (preferably more) external hard drives to insulate against hard drive failure on your main Mac.

4) Only after completing steps 2 and 3, go back and delete photos that you do not need immediately accessible on your phone. Keep the ones you absolutely want to have on your phone, knowing that you have full-resolution backups on Photos for macOS (and external hard drives) as well as your entire library available in the cloud on Google Photos which can be accessed anywhere that you have an internet connection. If you are judicious about preserving a selected number of "keepers" on your phone, you should rarely run into trouble with running out of space on your phone--at least not due to photos.

If you have a workflow and archival programs you'd like to share, leave a comment!