Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts

Saturday, January 17, 2026

Hospital Website Wiretapping Settlements

The Meta Pixel tracker was exposed many years ago for its nefarious practices of obtaining health-related information about patients from hospital websites, and I wrote about it here on June 25, 2022.

However, Meta/Facebook was not the only bad actor. Google and many other companies had also been known to “wiretap” hospital websites to collect protected health information (PHI). As a result, the Office of Civil Rights issued statements on the matter, along with warnings to hospital systems about the use of these online tracking technologies. I wrote about it here on July 23, 2023.

To summarize the legal issues, there is a healthcare-specific law called the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) which prohibits healthcare providers from sharing PHI with third parties. This law appears to have been repeated violated by the implementation of tracking technologies on hospital websites.

Yesterday I received a Notice of Proposed Class Action Settlement in which Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. reached a proposed settlement of claims related to their disclosure of patients’ confidential personal information due to third-party software code. The Consolidated Master Class Action Complaint specifically mentions Quantum Metric, Twitter, Adobe, Microsoft Bing, and Google as “Third Party Wiretappers” on paragraph 4 (page 2) and states that it is not limited to just these companies.

In paragraph 261 (page 74), it specifically mentions that Meta/Facebook and Google Analytics have been implicated in this specific tracking activity of personal health information.

There have been other lawsuits against other healthcare delivery organizations and resultant settlements. I used ChatGPT to help me identify some of them which include University of Tennessee Medical Center & Margaret Mary Community Hospital, Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center, Louisiana Children’s Medical Center, Reid Health, MarinHealth, and Eisenhower Medical Center to name some lawsuits in which Meta Pixel was specifically implicated. I have not done comprehensive research, but I suspect that there are many others in which other third party wiretappers are named. If you were a Kaiser patient between November 2017 and May 2024, and if you haven’t received notification about the Kaiser Privacy Breach Settlement, visit https://kaiserprivacysettlement.com to learn more.

Friday, April 21, 2023

Facebook User Privacy Settlement


If you were a Facebook user in the United States between May 24, 2007, and December 22, 2022, inclusive, you may be eligible for a cash payment from a Class Action Settlement. Numerous lawsuits were brought on behalf of Facebook users who allege that Facebook (now Meta Platforms, Inc.) shared or otherwise made accessible to third parties (including but not limited to third-party app developers, “whitelisted” parties, business partners, advertisers, and data brokers) user data and data about users’ friends without permission of the users whose data was shared, and did not sufficiently monitor and enforce third-party access or use of that data.

The Facebook User Privacy Settlement is known as In re: Facebook, Inc. Consumer Privacy User Profile Litigation, Case No. 3:18- md-02843-VC (N.D. Cal.), and Facebook denies that it violated any law but has agreed to the Settlement to avoid the costs and risks associated with continuing this case. The only way to receive a cash payment from this Settlement is by submitting a timely and properly completed Claim Form that obtains approval from the Settlement Administrator. The Claim Form must be submitted no later than August 25, 2023.

If the Settlement is approved by the Court, Meta will establish a Settlement Fund of seven hundred twenty-five million dollars ($725,000,000.00) to pay all valid claims submitted by the Settlement Class Members, as well as notice and administration expenses, any attorneys’ fees and costs, and any Service Awards for the Settlement Class Representatives. Your payment will depend on how many Settlement Class Members submit valid claims and how long you were a user on Facebook during the Class Period.

Saturday, June 25, 2022

Hospital Websites and Meta Pixel

Meta (the company formerly known as Facebook) is in the hot seat again, this time in conjunction with many hospitals and health systems across the country. A tracker called the Meta Pixel was discovered on many hospital websites, bringing into question once again how much you can trust third parties with your sensitive information. According to an article by The Markup, 33 of Newsweek’s top 100 hospitals in the country were sending sensitive data to Facebook via Meta Pixel as of June 15, 2022. The Meta Pixel tracker was found on multiple areas of hospital websites including appointment scheduling pages and password-protected patient portals. The information included medications, allergies, search terms for how doctors were found (e.g., “pregnancy termination”), and other data. Details of how The Markup obtained this information are provided here.

It is common knowledge to many individuals, particularly those who have watched The Social Dilemma, that Meta tracks personal information for its users. So why is the discovery of Meta Pixel such a big deal? In healthcare, a law called the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) prohibits “covered entities” like hospitals from sharing “protected health information” (PHI) with third parties like Meta.

A covered entity is an individual, organization, or agency that transmits personally identifiable information. It includes health care providers, health plans, and health care clearinghouses. The hospitals that were found to have Meta Pixel installed on their websites are covered entities.

PHI (a.k.a. “Individually identifiable health information” or “personally identifiable health information” or other variations) is defined as information, including demographic data, that relates to:

  • the individual’s past, present or future physical or mental health or condition,
  • the provision of health care to the individual, or
  • the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care to the individual,

and that identifies the individual or for which there is a reasonable basis to believe it can be used to identify the individual.

In other words, HIPAA law is written in a way that individuals and organizations who have access to patient information are expected to keep it private and only use it when necessary to deliver patient care, handle payment, or perform other permitted administrative functions. According to The Markup:

“I am deeply troubled by what [the hospitals] are doing with the capture of their data and the sharing of it,” said David Holtzman, a health privacy consultant who previously served as a senior privacy adviser in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights, which enforces HIPAA. “I cannot say [sharing this data] is for certain a HIPAA violation. It is quite likely a HIPAA violation.”

Meta Pixel has been the subject of several class action lawsuits in several states. Results have been mixed, and you read more about them in the “Legal Implications” section of the article by The Markup. Meanwhile, as patients and as users of technology, we have to ask ourselves if we trust social media and if we trust our hospitals to safeguard our health information.

Sunday, April 1, 2018

Accessing Your Facebook Data

Did you know that you can download your Facebook data? It's a simple 2-step process where you request your data and then wait for Facebook to notify you that your information is available for download. For me, the process took just a few minutes.



The above link describes how to request your data as well as all the categories of Facebook that can be reported to you. What's lurking in your Facebook data?

Saturday, October 8, 2016

Facebook Safety Check

While many people would agree that social media sites like Facebook have utility limited to entertainment or pure suckage of time, one interesting feature is Facebook Safety Check which was designed to allow people to communicate during disasters. As Hurricane Matthew threatens the Caribbean and the east coast of the United States, I could see value in this sort of service. To illustrate, here is the Facebook Safety Check banner from the Hurricane Matthew South Carolina page:


What has been your experience with Facebook Safety Check, and have you used it to communicate with your friends and relatives during disasters?

Friday, September 30, 2016

Facebook 'Mirror Boy' Controversy

Last night I posted a photo of myself on Facebook.  The subject of the photo was me when I was approximately 1 year old, standing naked in front of a mirror.  After all, it was Thursday, and given that it is one of my favorite childhood photos, I thought the photo was worthy of a #TBT hashtag.  This morning I received the following email from Facebook:


Upon visiting Facebook via desktop web browser, it forced me to login despite having previously stored my username and password in my browser (the same applied to my Facebook app for iOS).  Following successful login, rather than displaying my typical feed of UFC events, nature videos, and stories illustrating that Donald Trump possesses the emotional intelligence of a chick pea, I was presented with this message:


So take that, Facebook--that's me in my birthday suit for the whole world to see.  There was certainly no pornographic intent, and clearly I had consented to posting the image since I had carefully scanned and edited (rotating, cropping, tone adjustment, and other minor edits only--nothing that would require surgical intervention to correct) the photo before posting it to my own personal Facebook feed which I make visible only to my personal contacts.  If you read the Facebook Community Standards (referenced in the above image) language on nudity, the wording all falls under the section of "Encouraging respectful behavior" where nudity, hate speech, and violence and graphic content policies are described.  The 'Mirror Boy' photo was also not intended to be disrespectful, nor do I think that most people would perceive it to be disrespectful.  I wonder if Blogger (owned by Google) would censor this image too?  I guess I'll find out after I post this blog article.

On a related topic, a controversy recently unfolded about Facebook censoring the 'Napalm Girl' photo, and following much public criticism of Facebook's policy, the photo was reinstated across the site.  You can find articles about it here, here, and here, to highlight a few of the many stories written about it.  Coincidentally, both the 'Napalm Girl' and 'Mirror Boy' photos were taken in 1972.  Should I petition to reinstate the 'Mirror Boy' photo on my Facebook feed?